Skip to main content

ENG 101 Fall 2018: P.R.O.V.E.N Method

Crap detection

“Every man should have a built-in automatic crap detector operating inside him."    
          ~Ernest Hemingway, 1954

Why Evaluate web sources?

  • Anyone with a little time, some knowledge and small amount of money can publish on the Internet.
     
  • No person, persons or organization reviews the content of the Internet.
     
  • Pages are retrieved by search engines based on the page's content, not the relevancy or quality of the page.
     
  • Much information on the Web is not updated regularly.

It’s up to YOU to sort the accurate bits from the misinfo, disinfo, spam, scams, urban legends, and hoaxes. “Crap detection,” as Hemingway called it half a century ago, is more important than ever before.

 

Proven Method List

You be the Fact Checker

Video: Evaluating Sources

P.R.O.V.E.N Method

Have you P.R.O.V.E.N that your source is credible?

The following list of questions will help you to think critically while you evaluate the sources you find. 

Purpose: How and why the source was created.

  • How and why did the authors publish this information? Is it intended to educate, inform, persuade,sell, or entertain? Do the authors, publishers, or sponsors state this purpose, or try to disguise it?
  • Why was this information published in this particular type of source( book , article, website,blog, etc)?
  • Who is the intended audience? Is the source designed for the general public, students, or experts?

Relevance: The value of the source for your needs

  • Is the type of source appropriate for how you plan to use it, and for your assignments' requirements?
  • How useful is the information in this source, compated to other sources? Does it answer your questions or support your argument? Does it add something new and important to your knowledge of the topic?
  • How detailed is the information? Is it too general or too specific? Is it too basic or too advanced?

Objectivity: The reasonableness and completeness of the information

  • Do the authors present the information thoroughly and professionally? Do they critique other perspectives respective fully? Do they use strong, emotional, manipulative, or offensive language?
  • Do the authors, publishers, or sponsors have a particular political, ideological, cultural, or religious point of view? Do they acknowledge this point of view, or try to disguise it?
  • Is the information fact or opinion? Is it biased? Does this source present multiple points of view on the topic? Does it leave out, or make fun of, important facts or alternative perspectives?

Verifiability: The accuracy of the creators of the source

  • Do the authors support the information they present with strong factual evidence? Do they cite or provide links to other sources? Do those sources pass the P.R.O.V.E.N. test? 
  • What do experts say about the topic? Can you verify the information in other credible sources? 
  • Does the source contradict itself, include false statements, or misrepresent other sources?
  • Are there errors in spelling, punctuation, or grammar?

Expertise: The authority of the creators of the source.

  • What makes the authors, publishers, or sponsors of the source authorities on the topic? Do they have related education, personal or professional experience, or other expertise? Are they affiliated with an educational institution or respected organization? Is their expertise acknowledged by other authorities on the topic? Do they provide an important alternative perspective? Do other sources cite this source?
  • Has the source been reviewed in some way, such as by an editor or through peer review?  
  • Does the source provide contact information for the authors, publishers, and/or sponsors? 

Newness: The age of the information

  • Is your topic in an area that requires current information (such as science, technology, or current events), or could information found in older sources still be useful and valid?
  • When was the information presented in the source first published or posted? Are the references or links to other sources up to date? 
  • Are newer sources available that would add important information to your understanding of the topic?

 

   P.R.O.V.E.N. Source Evaluation by Ellen Carey is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/